Quote from: DaSpirit on September 24, 2014, 06:08:58 PM
One liners generally do not describe an opinion (unless of course, that line is really big), and those are types of topics we should be locking and avoiding in the first place.
But do you see much of that here ? Meaning inside the actual product sub forums and not the general or other ? An occasional humour or funny comment is good at times, people lead stressful lives as it is, nothing wrong with some humour, especially when the people involved understand the context. This is another big issue where people might be turned off.......CONTEXT. For people who have known each other for a long time, both outside and on the forums might understand the context of a certain term or post, whilst the person joining the community might feel offended or otherwise. Which is why I guess to keep it fair and square, the only way in my opinion is keeping the official forums about the product, professional and the other forums non related relaxed or have a section for debates and other, closed or open, at least people can't use an excuse to say they were turned away, when they could have avoided those sub forums.
By one liner in my comment, I do not mean ALL one liners. As there is room for properly using one liners and there is the misuse of one liners when it is non constructive, offensive, trolling ,etc.
Examples:
"Your product sucks major bollox"
"Your product is shite!"
"you guys sux!"
"Your product is garbage"
etc. You get the drift. These type of people are bad for any community. You don't have to even be a coder, just argument why you hate something and give your opinion as to what could make it better. Luckily for the most part I find this community to be more friendlier and helpful than many other communities I've seen.........I guess some people decide only to judge an entire community based on cherry picking the wrong posts......

Quote
Also, sure, the ENIGMA may be good too. But it is unorganized. Heck, it doesn't even have proper version numbers. We'll never know when we hit 1.0, and maybe we never will. This community and the product both reflect that same unprofessional vibe.
Spot on - I cannot agree more with this and had mentioned this before. Even in LGM, with all the changes made, it was stuck to 1.8.5, then got finally promoted to 1.8.6....... I think it deserves far more than a .001 increment

I guess to some ENIGMA is work in progress, and might always be.......but in all fairness I think the same of "other" products too

Quote
We have a potentially very peaceful community. While friends do curse at each other, for fun, outsiders can and will be insulted. We cannot choose who comes
Spot on again, your views align exactly with what I mentioned above, and I had not read your comment yet... CONTEXT..... People who know each other for a while vs. an outsider who will interpret it different. Obviously you are not going to greet a stranger on the street with "Hey there MFka.....

" or call some random person a dumb B*

So yeah, there is the common stereotype that this type of behaviour is only for pre-teens, kids, teens ,etc...... LOL I beg to differ, there are probably as much adults if not more. I have actually witnessed this quite a lot........Radio personalities, TV personalities, celebrities, judges, law enforcement.......TEACHERS (yes even at the University level) some of the stuff I witnessed and heard - you'd think some 12 year olds are more mature.......but anyhow that's for another topic. On the good side, some of these people can be really nice and helpful towards others, they may act this way amongst their peers, friends, etc.
Quote
here, but we should set examples for any new users or new contributors.
True, but at the same time we should not be robots. A bit of fun, humour and what not....is good ! Perhaps certain things belong in their own sub forums, I agree.
I have seen many highly disturbing terms or topics here that would not only turn away people but cause people to report the site (very serious stuff) but mostly they are posted outside the official forums......Which is why it is important to keep these areas restricted and not open to non registered or new members.
Quote
Still, right now, maybe we need more, or better, moderators to moderate the existing moderators. I know that Josh does not want more moderators, but we need more control here.
You want moderators on a forum with 4 active posters, most by developers ?

Fact is the forum is not the whole deal.
People might be turned off because they get scared of ENIGMA, having the impression that it is not a FINISHED product (well er. it isn't

) or being scared by the license or scared by open source, or scared by the bugs or what not, who knows.......I guess with the mobility CRAZE, it seems unlikely ENIGMA will attract many people. The day ENIGMA will be complete + multi platform export etc, that might change.......though I think what ENIGMA needs is a complete detachment from the umbilical cord - it should have been cut off ages ago, and for the sake of compatibility might be paying the price now. One thing about ENIGMA community, there is more freedom of people to express themselves and not being censored or bashed by moderators, admins, or banned because you disagree.......OR for users to insult newbies like some people called out on the GMC recently by users here......

So one has to look at both sides of the coin.
To what extent is moderation and censorship needed ? and where?
Is it more logical to moderate the official areas and keep other sub forums off limits,
or other methods?
Quote
We need somebody who says "hey, chill" and warns others whenever something potentially insulting is said, because some of our current members don't notice this behavior.
Feuds between users.......flaming, etc.
Perhaps there should be a sub forum, (closed area / restricted) for certain type of heated debates that has potential to turn sour. Things can go south quickly - Some people might choose the easy way out of just avoiding stuff, but why ? I am a strong believer of freedom of expression, but also believe in sub sections and moderation (NOT censorship).
Because too much censorship or excessive moderation might have the opposite effect......actual helpful contributors or users being pushed away. Some people, as in real life, can appear mean on the outside core and "bad ass!"

but are skilled and can be really helpful and beneficial. Welcome to life

Big debates, heated topics, controversial topics people are usually afraid to discuss, I'm all for it......but they should definitely be restricted areas OUTSIDE the official forums....and a good disclaimer should be added to a forum.